Aggies Dominate the Field, Not the Rankings: The Poll Problem in College Football
Week One is supposed to be about setting the tone, but for the Aggies, their 42–24 win over UTSA didn’t move the needle in the polls. Texas A&M dropped one spot to No. 22 in the Coaches Poll and stayed put at No. 19 in the AP Poll, leaving many supporters scratching their heads. On paper, a near 20-point win to open the season looks robust, yet poll voters seem unconvinced that this squad has made the dive into national contention. It’s an unsatisfying reality for a program that has invested heavily in recruiting talent and coaching, only to see unenthusiastic reactions from the national stage. The question now is whether this is a sign of doubt in the Aggies or simply the growing pains of proving consistency in a crowded college football landscape.
Part of the reason Texas A&M’s win didn’t resonate may come down to perception more than performance. UTSA is no pushover, but they’re not the kind of opponent that excites pollsters, especially when other ranked teams opened their seasons with marquee victories. The Aggies’ offense looked balanced and efficient, and the defense created key stops, yet critics point to sloppy moments that could haunt them against elite competition. With Utah State up next, the Aggies are facing what most consider a tune-up game before the real test arrives on September 13th against Notre Dame. That looming clash with the Fighting Irish will be the measuring stick for where A&M truly belongs in the national conversation. Until then, the Aggies will need to crack down on their execution and prove that their win over UTSA wasn’t just a stat-padding performance.
Nat’s Prediction
Looking ahead, I expect the Aggies to handle Utah State with relative ease, likely winning by three or more touchdowns. Texas A&M’s offensive line should dominate the trenches, opening lanes for the run game while keeping the passing attack sharp and efficient. Where I’ll be watching closely is on defense; this is where A&M must tighten up and show that they can finish drives without giving up costly big plays. If the Aggies deliver a clean, convincing win, they might earn more respect heading into their marquee battle with Notre Dame. Until they prove it on the big stage, poll voters will remain skeptical. My call? Texas A&M cruises past Utah State but still stays outside the top 15 until after September 13th. That game against Notre Dame won’t just be a test; it will be a statement of opportunity that defines their 2025 season.
