The New York Giants have had a great start to their season. They are thriving in every aspect except one: their special teams kicker, Dominic Zvada. Big Blue has reached a point where they don’t know whether to trust him to attempt a field goal. This kicker has missed six field goals in nine games. It may be time for New York to turn to someone else to make sure those extra points land.
Zvada started with a pretty promising outcome in New York. This young rookie had won the kicking competition to earn the starting role as the team's kicker. However, he is now costing them games in the worst way possible. In the team's most recent game against the Commanders, this rookie kicker was one of the main reasons the team fell after missing a field goal.
His missed kicks come at the most inopportune moments. Not all of New York’s losses come from missed field goals, but the former Wolverine has missed several games where those points were needed. He first missed when the Giants took on the Commanders for the first time this season. In that game, he missed three needed field goals, sending both teams into overtime and costing the Giants the chance to take the lead.
The Big Ten kicking sensation then missed two field goals again when the Giants took on the Houston Texans before their bye week. Those missed kicks sent New York into another overtime game. It wasn’t a good look, and the team had to work harder than planned, despite the win. That trend has continued and carried into their most recent game against Washington. Big Blue cannot keep going like this. They need a reliable kicker who can be consistent and get the job done.
Head coach John Harbaugh is hopeful that Zvada’s kicking may turn around before the end of the season. However, most of this rookie's missed kicks come from the fifty-yard line or further. If the former Michigan standout is closer than this, he may be able to make the field goal. However, in the second game against the Commanders, he missed a 33-yard field goal. Harbaugh is persistent that he can improve. If the 2026 rookie misses scoring drives this upcoming week, the Giants may need to take time to evaluate what they need at this position. New York’s sideline general believes that it is a mechanism issue with the right hash mark. They may be able to fix this issue before it is too late. It won’t happen overnight, but this placekicker may need a lot of work.
The Giants should start discussing their options in the coming weeks. They are playing against teams with stronger drives. This team needs to prioritize the wins, find ways to bounce back, and make the necessary adjustments to restore confidence in their kicking game. This team has already seen how costly missed kicks have become. It’s time to find something better, because every point counts at this point in the season.
