Pros and Cons of Resigning a 22-Year-Old Defenseman: What’s Best for the Devils?
As the 2025–26 preseason approaches, one burning question lingers for Devils fans: Will Luke Hughes re-sign with New Jersey? The young defenseman has already shown immense talent and looks set to be a key part of the Devils’ defense for years to come. However, they are having a hard time getting him to sign a contract. The Devils either want him to sign an eight-year, long-term deal or a shorter bridge contract. While Hughes prefers a five-year contract, which would align with his brother, Jack Hughes.
Last season, the Devils finished 43-33-7, earning them a playoff spot, ultimately falling in the first round to the Carolina Hurricanes. They still have some work if they want to be seen as serious contenders. Will securing Luke Hughes be the move that helps the Devils reach the next level? Or could committing to such a young player limit them? How they handle Hughes’s contract could set the tone for the Devils’ next chapter.
The outcome of these negotiations has a big impact on the Devils’ future. Hughes has made a name for himself in New Jersey; with seven goals and 37 assists last season, he has proved he has the potential to grow into one of the league’s top defensemen. Plus, with his average time on ice being 21:17 and his ability to contribute effectively on both sides of the ice, Hughes has shown he can be relied on in key situations. The Devils have also been trying to acquire the Vancouver Canucks captain, and the eldest Hughes brother, Quinn Hughes. Keeping Luke Hughes is a vital factor to make that happen.
Even with his impressive performance over the last three years, there are still questions about how it might impact the team moving forward. Hughes is still developing his game and hasn’t proven consistency over multiple seasons. If the Devils lock him in for eight years, there’s no real way of knowing he will reach his full potential. With a recorded total of 155 giveaways and only 76 takeaways in his three years as a Devil, Hughes tends to turn the puck over more than he recovers it. This is an important consideration for a defenseman who is on the ice for over 20 minutes per game. Giveaways at that rate negatively impact the defense’s stability and scoring opportunities.
Ultimately, the decision to resign Luke Hughes comes down to potential. He wants to specifically have a five-year contract aligning with Jack Hughes so they both have leverage when they become free agents. So far, he has already proven that he can be a contributing factor and has the skill to grow into a top defenseman for the Devils. On the other hand, his turnovers and ongoing development could make a long-term deal a risk. Whether the Devils decide to opt for a bridge deal, a long-term extension, or to meet his five-year request, the choice will significantly impact New Jersey’s roster and its future as a playoff contender. Fans will be watching closely as this decision could help shape the franchise for years to come.
