Which Starting Receiver Should the Saints Keep?
The New Orleans Saints are facing an important decision at wide receiver, trying to determine which player to build around for the future. Two options stand out: Chris Olave and Rashid Shaheed. While both have shown flashes of talent and playmaking ability, it is clear that the team should prioritize Chris Olave as their cornerstone receiver. Olave’s combination of youth, versatility, and high upside makes him the better long-term option for a Saints offense looking to remain competitive. With another year left on his rookie contract before an extension is necessary, the team has time to continue developing him without rushing financial decisions.
Consistency and health are key factors in evaluating any player, and both Olave and Shaheed have experienced ups and downs in their careers so far. Shaheed’s speed is his primary asset, but it comes with limitations in route running and overall versatility. Olave, on the other hand, has proven he can line up in multiple positions, run a diverse route tree, and make plays in a variety of situations. His ability to contribute in various roles makes him easier to build around, whether in the passing game or in more creative offensive schemes. Over time, Olave is more likely to provide steady production while maintaining his health and consistency as a starter.
Another advantage for the Saints is that Shaheed’s unique skill set, primarily his speed, can be replaced through the draft or free agency. In contrast, Olave’s combination of size, hands, and route-running is more challenging to replicate. Trading or moving Shaheed could also provide the team with valuable draft capital, even in the mid-rounds, which could be reinvested into improving the roster elsewhere. By keeping Olave and finding a replacement for Shaheed’s speed, the Saints can strike a balance between immediate production and long-term planning. This approach also allows the team to maximize Olave’s high ceiling while maintaining roster flexibility.
In conclusion, Chris Olave represents the most logical choice for the Saints to keep as a starting receiver moving forward. He is younger, more versatile, and offers higher upside than Rashid Shaheed, making him easier to build the offense around. Olave’s skill set suits a variety of roles and schemes, providing the Saints with more options while ensuring consistency and reliability. Meanwhile, Shaheed’s speed, while valuable, is more easily replaceable, and trading him could provide the team with additional assets. Focusing on Olave allows the Saints to prioritize development, stability, and long-term success at a key offensive position.
