Why This Former South Carolina QB has the Edge In Saints QB Competition
As the New Orleans Saints progress through training camp, one of the key storylines is the quarterback competition between Spencer Rattler, Jake Haener, and Tyler Shough. So far, Rattler appears to have a slight edge, thanks mainly to his experience starting six games last season and having a full year in an NFL system. That continuity is proving valuable in camp, especially as Rattler demonstrates poise, timing, and command in Kellen Moore’s offense. While Haener is still in the mix, it's Rattler and Shough who have drawn the most attention as possible long-term answers.
Rattler’s experience gives him a steadiness the other two haven’t quite matched. His timing with receivers has looked sharper, and his decisions under pressure seem more consistent than Shough’s or Haener’s. While he doesn’t have elite arm strength, Rattler is showing a good grasp of timing routes and reads something critical in Moore’s system. The Saints also have a strong offensive line and speedy playmakers on the outside, which helps create a favorable environment for a QB like Rattler, who thrives when protected and in rhythm. His growth since entering the league is clear, and he’s capitalizing on that momentum early in camp.
Tyler Shough, meanwhile, may have the highest physical upside of the three with his size and arm talent, but he’s showing signs that he’s not quite NFL-ready. Reports from camp highlight issues with accuracy and decision-making, especially when the tempo increases. Shough often gets sped up, leading to off-target throws and rushed reads that kill drives. These are common rookie challenges, but they suggest he may need more time to adjust before being thrown into a real game situation. Still, his natural tools make him an intriguing developmental option for Moore and the staff.
The situation is far from settled, and preseason action will likely determine who ultimately wins the job. Kellen Moore hasn’t tipped his hand yet, and he’ll want to see how each quarterback handles live defenses and game situations. The Saints have done a good job building an offense that can support a young quarterback, with a solid offensive line and fast weapons outside to stretch the field. That could allow someone like Rattler to manage the offense effectively while still developing. Until then, the reps in practice and games will be critical, and Rattler’s early lead is just one step in a much larger decision-making process.
In conclusion, Spencer Rattler’s early advantage in the Saints’ quarterback competition is grounded in his game experience, command of the offense, and composure under pressure. Tyler Shough may have more raw talent, but his camp performance shows he’s still adjusting to the speed and complexity of the pro game. The battle is still wide open, with preseason games expected to be the actual test of who can lead the team. For now, Rattler’s steady hand makes him the favorite, but nothing is set in stone. With solid talent around them and a creative offensive coordinator in Moore, whoever wins the job will have the tools to succeed.
