With Knicks Core Retained After the 2026 NBA All-Star Break, Who’s the Odd Man Out?
As the second half of the NBA season begins to take shape, the New York Knicks face important rotational decisions. The starting lineup has remained consistent for much of the year, but the second unit remains fluid as head coach Mike Brown continues to evaluate combinations. A year ago, New York’s bench was viewed as one of the weaker groups in the Eastern Conference. Through adjustments during the offseason, NBA free agency, internal development, and recent additions, the roster now looks considerably deeper. Since taking over for Tom Thibodeau, Brown has shown a willingness to experiment with matchups and pace. With the arrivals of Jose Alvarado and Jeremy Sochan in recent weeks, the question inside Madison Square Garden is simple: Who becomes the odd man out when the rotation tightens?
Miles McBride, currently recovering from core muscle surgery, is expected to reclaim his role as leader of the second unit once healthy. Mitchell Robinson, when available, remains one of the league’s most dominant offensive rebounders and interior defenders. The Knicks are 25-14 when Robinson plays, reinforcing his value as a foundational piece down the stretch. Landry Shamet has also strengthened his case for steady minutes, posting career-best marks in points per game and three-point percentage, an essential element in today’s perimeter-driven NBA. Regardless of McBride’s timeline, Alvarado has already made his presence felt, including a 26-point performance in under 20 minutes during a blowout win against the Philadelphia 76ers. His defensive pressure and tempo fit seamlessly within Brown’s system.
The addition of Sochan off waivers further complicates the rotation, particularly in the frontcourt. With Guerschon Yabusele no longer in the picture and depth previously stretched thin, Sochan provides versatility at both forward spots. Historically, Brown has leaned toward a nine-man rotation, meaning difficult decisions are inevitable. One player who stands out as vulnerable is Jordan Clarkson. The former Sixth Man of the Year Award winner has enjoyed scoring bursts throughout his career, but inconsistent shot selection and defensive limitations have resulted in multiple DNPs this season. Despite speculation about his long-term fit, both Clarkson and the organization remain aligned in pursuit of postseason success and a potential run through the NBA Playoffs.
Tyler Kolek and Mohamed Diawara have each shown flashes in expanded opportunities. Kolek’s ability to operate as a pass-first guard and knock down perimeter shots has energized stretches of games, while Diawara’s defensive activity and disciplined shot profile have earned praise. However, as the regular season intensifies and games begin to mirror postseason intensity, experience often outweighs potential. With the Knicks firmly positioned near the top of the Eastern Conference standings and aiming to build upon last season’s trip to the Eastern Conference Finals, the emphasis is clearly on veteran reliability. The recent additions signal that New York is fully committed to competing for an NBA Finals appearance. When April arrives, a shortened, veteran-heavy rotation may ultimately determine whether the Knicks can take the final step toward championship contention.
