The New York Giants came into the 2026 season expecting big things from their running back room under new head coach John Harbaugh. However, six weeks into the 2026 campaign, the Giants are still looking to establish a polished running game. If Colts star Jonathan Taylor hits the trade block, he may be exactly what the G-men need. Taylor is a three-time Pro Bowler and one of the NFL's best running backs. Suddenly, he's become a name to watch, and he could be dealt before the November 10th trade deadline. As Indianapolis struggles to find its footing, mounting uncertainty surrounding the Colts’ future has ignited a compelling debate over whether the franchise should part ways with its star running back.
According to news outlets, multiple teams have discussed possibly making a deal for Taylor. The Colts haven't confirmed whether they will trade him, but these rumors have the G-Men interested. The New Yorks' biggest backfield problem this season has been finding a starting running back. Cam Skattebo, Tyrone Tracy, and Devin Singletary have all had chances to prove themselves, and each has underwhelmed. Mounting ball-security concerns have raised pressing questions about the reliability and consistency of the Giants’ rushing attack; both ‘Skatt’ and Tracy have fumbled, resulting in fewer snaps. The former NFL rushing champion would quickly give the Giants a legit starting back. The 27-year-old phenom has racked up more than 8,000 rushing yards since entering the league and has made himself a household name. He came into this season off a stellar 2025 campaign, with 1,963 total yards and 20 total scores. For a team looking to stay on top of the NFC East, adding the former Pro Bowler could elevate this offense.
Trading for the Colts star offers many benefits, but it also comes with major risks. The Colts signed the former Wisconsin Badgers standout to a two-year, $44 million deal, keeping him under contract through 2028. This means the Colts' asking price wouldn't be low. The Giants need to weigh their options and decide whether they are willing to give up future draft picks for the back; it's worth it. The G-Men have many other areas that need improvement, such as the offensive line and secondary. The question is what the Giants value the most. Ultimately, Taylor could provide the offensive firepower the Giants need to elevate their rushing attack, but acquiring a game-changing talent shouldn't come at the expense of the franchise’s long-term vision and championship aspirations. A star player is great, but a complete team matters more.
